developments, in the hope that a bird’s-eye view will provide these volumes with breadth and unity that might otherwise be lacking. The aim is not to deal with denominational bodies (e.g., the Missouri Synod or the Southern Baptist Convention) or particular publications that have agonized over the issue (e.g., Churchman) but to focus on theological, philosophical, and historical matters that in the modern debate impinge directly on how we view the Bible. The resurgence of interest in the doctrine